Pompeii3 Reviews

I ordered a ring from this website but it looked drastically different when it arrived. Looked cheaper and the stone which was supposed to be refracted morganite was a cloudy and dull in colour. The metal was light and felt cheap. Sent it back and got a refund but not for shipping. Be careful.

Ok, so here's the Reader's Digest Condensed version of this purchase: I bought the 14k White Gold 2ct TDW Forever Us Two Stone Engagement Diamond Ring from Pompeii 3 through Overstock.com, with the understanding the main diamonds were i2/i3, and when I gave the ring to my fiancee, she noticed a black inclusion in one of the diamonds.  I contacted Customer Service at Overstock, and they acted as the "middle man" between me and Pompeii 3, and let them know I wasn't happy about the inclusion, especially since the other main diamond didn't have one. So, I sent the ring back to Pompeii 3, and that's when the "fun" began.  First, the tell me they can't replace the ring because it has scratches on the bottom of the ring. Well, my fiancee had only been wearing it a few days, and she works in an office environment, so, I don't know how many scratches it could've had, not to mention, they could've simply used Rhodium to resurface the ring.  Anyway, after a lot of back and forth through Overstock, we came to a 'compromise'...they would simply change the diamond with the black inclusion for one that was similar, but without a visible inclusion.  Reasonable compromise I thought...until I got the ring back yesterday, and in what seems to me as an act of spite, especially since I called them out and gave them a difficult time, the diamond they replaced the original one with is worse than the original one. It does have an inclusion, however, it's clarity is worse then the original...it now looks cloudy.  I mean seriously...are they that petty? I asked for a diamond that more closely matched the diamond they didn't replace, and they went in the other direction. I seriously and honestly don't think anyone should be anything from this place, especially since they seem to be, and least in my perspective, petty and spiteful, and they seemingly don't care about service after the sale, and seemingly don't stand behind their products especially when you complain about their product. Based on what they've done, I should've had them simply send the ring back as it was, because now it's worse.  I will be posting this review in other social media sites as well as other business review sites.  I'm even considering checking if IL has an office of Consumer Affairs within the State Attorney General's office and contacting them.

I bought a ring, a pair of earrings and a necklace all at the same time.
The ring was advertised as 0.5 CTW, but it was actually 0.4 CTW when it came. The diamonds are not clear, they have a yellow tint.
The earrings were supposed to be nine small diamonds in a 3x3 square. The diamonds were different sizes, so the earrings are not perfect squares. Also, the diamonds have a yellow tint.
The necklace never arrived.
The prices are nice, so if you don't look close enough, you won't be able to tell the difference. I, personally, won't be using them again.